Research program

Innovation and Productivity Strategies

IPS is the research program of the institute. It develops models that leaders can deploy across the enterprise, along the full stream from research ideas to customer experiences in goods and services.

Composite model

Four domains, working together

Used together, Strategy, Process, Organization, and Tools explain more than models with fewer drivers, because each domain reinforces the others. The pattern varies from research laboratories to services. Practices are measured so teams can adopt and adapt them.

Figure

The composite model

StrategySStrategyProcessPProcessOrganizationOOrganizationTools/TechnologiesTTools/Technologies
Four SPOT domains deployed together. The six two-way arrows mark the synergistic interactions among them.Source: Hull, Driving Cost-Effective Innovation with Concurrent Systems
Strategy
Formulate, implement, and adapt goals with the people responsible for doing the work.
Process
Deploy disciplined but flexible methods to design and produce customer offerings.
Organization
Bring diverse specialists together early, making product decisions throughout the development cycle.
Tools/Technologies
Extend human capability for design and production, using tools to communicate and collaborate.

Cross-functional teams give specialists room to form new product concepts. Process discipline then guides that work toward customer requirements at a manageable cost. Organization accounts for about 40 percent of the difference in time, cost, quality, and innovation. Process adds about 10 percent. Using both adds about 15 percent more.

Figure

Organizational collaboration and requirements process

Organization: 40%Process: 10%Synergy (O × P): 15%Unexplained: 35%65%explained
  • Organization40%
  • Process10%
  • Synergy (O × P)15%
  • Unexplained35%
Organization, process, and the synergistic interaction of both simultaneously explain 65% of why some enterprises achieve higher performance than others—a significant competitive advantage.Source: Hull, Driving Cost-Effective Innovation with Concurrent Systems

Field manual

Benchmarking concurrent practices

Benchmark an enterprise against Best-in-Class standards and rank the gaps by how strongly each practice drives performance. The BIG BANG score multiplies the size of the gap by the strength of that relationship, so teams can pursue the largest gain for the least change.

Explore the SPOT diagnostic
  1. 01

    Current practice

    Estimate how often stakeholders in the enterprise use each development practice.
  2. 02

    Best-in-Class standard

    Compare that rate with the standard observed in the SPOT III database.
  3. 03

    Gap

    Subtract the enterprise score from the Best-in-Class standard.
  4. 04

    Driver

    Weigh the practice by how strongly it tracks time, cost, quality, and innovation.
  5. 05

    Predicted performance

    Read the share of the performance difference associated with that practice.
  6. 06

    BIG BANG rank

    Multiply the gap by the strength of the driver. Higher scores are the changes most likely to matter.

Worksheet preview

Benchmark and prioritize best development practices

Illustrative SPOT worksheet
PracticeYour % of timeBest-in-Class %GapDriverBIG BANG
Strategy: Strategize with multiple functions: engage varied specialists in formulating goals.609030.412
Process: Upgrade models of your product development process by continually incorporating lessons learned by project teams.709020.48
Organization: Organize influence by downstream functions like manufacturing and service to have input to product development decisions at the concept phase.509040.416
Tools/Technologies: Lay out agile production operations by cross-training people and flexibly arranging multipurpose tools/technologies.809010.44
Average of four practices659025.410
Illustrative values. Stakeholders rate how much of the time each practice is used. Gap = Best-in-Class − your score, and BIG BANG = gap × driver. The higher the BIG BANG, the greater the impact of the practice on performance outcomes.Source: SPOT field manual, Best-in-Class standards from the SPOT III database

Publications

From Research to the Book

Cover of Driving Cost-Effective Innovation with Concurrent Systems

Driving Cost-Effective Innovation with Concurrent Systems

This book quantifies best practices for developing innovative products cost-effectively. Analyses of dozens of studies show how managing the work of people collaborating in parallel creates products faster, cheaper, and better in any organization. Concurrent systems deploy four kinds of practice simultaneously to synergistically achieve high performance: Strategy, Process, Organization, and Tools/Technologies (SPOT).

Appendices in every chapter enable stakeholders to benchmark their practices against Best-in-Class standards and identify gaps. A "Big Bang" index prioritizes best practices for improvement. A Composite Model™ algorithm enables designers of product development systems to further boost performance capabilities by combining complementary practices additively and synergistically. Managers and stakeholders collaborate in using these unique methods to build a "should be" vision of value development by closing gaps in their "as is" system to achieve diverse competitive advantages.

Case studies highlight how dozens of enterprises have successfully implemented SPOT practices to improve their performance. A transformation assurance process (TAP) provides tactics for champions to co-lead a five-step change journey: (1) Envisioning, (2) Diagnosing, (3) Assessing, (4) Implementing, and (5) Improving.

Read Chapter 2: Axiomatic Logic for the Composite Model

Benchmark your enterprise against Best-in-Class standards

Request a diagnostic